SEOptimize.3 of 20 seats openFree consultation
Contractor case study

Across 7 Weeks of Asphalt AI Checks, Bart's Was the Most-Cited Contractor Site

Across 7 weekly scans (weeks of 28 Sep to 9 Nov 2026) of 40 local asphalt questions on ChatGPT, Gemini, Google AI Overviews and AI Mode, 1,066 of 4,709 AI answers cited bartsasphalt.com, more than any other contractor's website in those answers (anthonysasphalt.com 357, mckearneyasphalt.com 346). Only Google (1,799) and Angi (1,393) were cited more. On four price questions for Ann Arbor and Lansing, with all questions and tools pooled, AI cited Bart's in 367 of 540 answers, ahead of Angi (254) and ProMatcher (238). The asphalt paving cost guide, published 18 March 2026, is the most-cited page on the site, at 245 answers.

Stat
1,066 of 4,709
Label
AI answers that cited bartsasphalt.com
Stat
1,066 vs 357
Label
Against the next contractor website, anthonysasphalt.com
Stat
367 of 540
Label
Answers to four local price questions that cited the site, all tools pooled (Angi 254, ProMatcher 238)
Stat
245 of 4,709
Label
AI answers that cited the paving cost guide, the most-cited page on the site

AI tools answer an asphalt question in their own words, with a few linked sources underneath. SEOptimize wrote the paving and sealcoating cost guides on the company blog. Across the 40 questions we track, bartsasphalt.com is cited more often than any other paving contractor website, and the page AI cites most is the paving cost guide we wrote.

01 Background

Who Is Bart's Asphalt?

Bart's Asphalt is a Michigan asphalt contractor. Its crews pave, sealcoat, repair and stripe parking lots and driveways, and its service pages cover towns across southern Michigan, including Lansing and Ann Arbor.

Their pages speak to commercial property owners as well as homeowners, from school districts to private driveways.

What Sets Them Apart

  1. 01

    Commercial depth. Dedicated pages for school districts, apartment complexes, churches, manufacturing plants and health care facilities.

  2. 02

    Prices out in the open. The blog publishes cost guides for asphalt paving, sealcoating, driveway sealcoating in Michigan, asphalt by the square foot and millings driveways.

  1. The Challenge

    Bart's had the crews and the commercial service pages, but someone pricing a driveway or a parking lot can put the question to ChatGPT, Gemini or Google and get a written answer that links to a handful of websites. Marketplaces and cost directories compete hard for those spots.

    The Solution

    We wrote cost guides that each answer one price question and treated AI answers as part of the job rather than an extra.

02 The Problem: Price Questions Answered Before the Click

AI tools can answer a price question before the searcher opens a contractor website.

Context

A property manager in Ann Arbor can ask ChatGPT what commercial sealcoating costs. The reply comes back as a written answer, with links to the sites it drew on. Google does the same in its AI Overview and in AI Mode.

Gap

The competition for those links isn't just other paving crews. Angi, a home-services marketplace, and ProMatcher, a paving cost directory, chase the same price questions in the same cities.

Impact

A contractor missing from the sources has fewer chances to be in front of the person pricing the job, at the moment they are weighing up the cost.

Significance

Those answers come from ChatGPT, Gemini, Google's two AI features and other tools. The goal was for the company's own pages to be among the sources they link to.

03 Strategy: SEOptimize's Game Plan

AI-search work is part of every SEOptimize engagement.

For this client, the plan came down to one move:

  1. 1.

    One guide per price question. Give each common cost question its own page, so an AI tool hunting for a Michigan asphalt price finds a page that answers exactly that.

04 Execution: Our Approach

  1. 01

    The Cost Guides

    We published the asphalt paving cost guide on the company blog in March 2026. It's one page that answers one question: what asphalt paving costs.

    We followed with a sealcoating cost guide, published in May 2026, and finished work on a guide to the price of asphalt per square foot the same month. They joined a driveway sealcoating cost guide for Michigan, live since September 2025, and work on a guide to the cost of a millings driveway finished in August 2026.

  2. 02

    Wider Site Work

    We checked the site-wide business structured data (Organization and LocalBusiness) every month from September 2026 to November 2026.

  3. 03

    AI-Search Work

    Our AI-search work for the company runs alongside the rest of the SEO work. The aim is to get its pages cited in AI Overviews and AI assistants as well as in the plain search results.

Timeline

  1. September 2025. Michigan driveway sealcoating guide published.
  2. March 2026. Paving cost guide published.
  3. May 2026. Sealcoating cost guide published; work finished on the per-square-foot guide.
  4. August 2026. Work finished on the millings driveway guide.
  5. From September 2026 to November 2026. Monthly checks of the site-wide business structured data.

05 Outcome: The Results

Across 7 weekly scans, from the week of 28 September to the week of 9 November 2026, 1,066 of the 4,709 AI answers to the 40 tracked questions cited bartsasphalt.com. That is nearly three times anthonysasphalt.com, the next contractor website, at 357, and only Google, at 1,799, and Angi, at 1,393, were cited more. The page AI cited most on the site is the paving guide. We wrote it.

  • Top three, every week. In all 7 weeks, bartsasphalt.com was one of the 3 most-cited sites, with no site other than Google or Angi ahead of it. It stayed ahead of every other contractor website.

  • Ahead of the cost directory. ProMatcher's three subdomains (counted as one) were cited in 406 answers, well under the site's 1,066, and the contractor mckearneyasphalt.com in 346.

  • Cited by all four AI tools. Gemini cited the site in 495 of 1,400 scans, AI Mode in 205 of 1,400, ChatGPT in 171 of 1,400 and AI Overviews in 195 of 883 scans.

Who AI Answers Cite: Bart's Against the Field

Bart's is the most-cited contractor website on 40 tracked asphalt questionsAI answers citing each site, 7 weekly scans, weeks of 28 Sep to 9 Nov 2026
google.com1,799
angi.com1,393
bartsasphalt.com1,066
anthonysasphalt.com357
mckearneyasphalt.com346

Source: GEO/AEO Command Center weekly scans (collected through DataForSEO), ChatGPT, Gemini, Google AI Overviews and AI Mode, 40 local asphalt questions, 5 runs per question per tool per week; subdomains merged (maps.google.com, request.angi.com); other directories, all cited less than Bart's, not shown · weeks of 28 Sep to 9 Nov 2026 · pulled 2026-11-11

Google and Angi top the chart, and every other contractor site sits far below Bart's.

Price Questions in Ann Arbor and Lansing

On the four price questions (asphalt paving cost in Ann Arbor and in Lansing, asphalt repair cost in Lansing and commercial sealcoating cost in Ann Arbor), pooled across the four questions and tools, 367 of 540 answers cited Bart's. Angi drew 254 and ProMatcher 238. The site led both in each of the 7 weeks.

  • AI Overviews: Google showed an AI Overview 120 times on these questions, and 119 of them cited the site.

  • Commercial sealcoating in Ann Arbor: 126 of 133 answers cited Bart's, including all 35 from ChatGPT and all 28 AI Overviews shown. The sealcoating cost guide was among the pages cited in 122 of them.

Four price questions, all tools pooled: AI cited Bart's ahead of Angi and ProMatcherAnswers citing each site, of 540 answers to four Ann Arbor and Lansing price questions
bartsasphalt.com367
angi.com254
promatcher.com238
anthonysasphalt.com72

Source: GEO/AEO Command Center weekly scans (collected through DataForSEO), all four AI tools pooled, 4 price questions, 540 answers (one search showed no AI Overview); Angi's and ProMatcher's subdomains merged · weeks of 28 Sep to 9 Nov 2026 · pulled 2026-11-11

Pooled across the four questions and the four AI tools, the contractor site leads both the marketplace and the cost directory. The lead does not hold on every tool or question: on ChatGPT alone, ProMatcher (56) and Angi (49) were cited more than Bart's (43), and on the Lansing repair question Angi led, 96 to 67.

The Paving Cost Guide

The guide was cited in 245 of the 4,709 AI answers. That is the most of any page on the site, ahead of the Lansing sealcoating service-area page at 163 and the sealcoating cost guide at 122. AI Overviews cited the paving guide 105 times and AI Mode 81 times, more than ChatGPT or Gemini did.

How We Measured This

Window:
7 weekly scans, from the week of 28 September to the week of 9 November 2026. Scanning began in the week of 28 September 2026. The first answers were collected on 2 October, so this compares the site with the others in the same answers, rather than a before and after.
Questions and tools:
40 local asphalt questions, none naming a company, each run 5 times a week on ChatGPT, Gemini and the two Google features by our GEO/AEO Command Center. The app collects every answer through DataForSEO. Perplexity and Claude were not scanned.
AI answers:
40 questions, run 5 times each on 4 tools every week for 7 weeks, make 5,600 scheduled scans, and every one ran. 517 Google AI Overview pulls returned an error and are left out, which leaves 5,083 scans; in 374 of them Google showed no AI Overview, which leaves 4,709 AI answers. On the four price questions, 560 scans ran, 19 returned an error and one showed no AI Overview, leaving 540 answers. No scheduled scan was missed; every gap is an error.
Citations:
an answer cites a site when it links to one of its pages. Subdomains count with their main site: maps.google.com with Google, request.angi.com with Angi and ProMatcher's three subdomains as one. Counts are pooled over the 7 weeks, because a single week is too small a sample to read alone.
Note:
ChatGPT moved from gpt-5-6 to gpt-6 from the week of 12 October, and the week after, answers cited more sites across the board, Bart's included; that week is part of the pooled counts, as it is for every other site. Gemini's last week mixes two model versions, and that week is part of the pooled counts. AI Overview pulls returned errors on about half the searches in 5 of the 7 weeks. The price-question lead is pooled: on ChatGPT alone, and on the Lansing repair question, Angi or ProMatcher were cited more. The sealcoating cost guide was edited on 22 October 2026, during the scan window; its 122 citations include answers from before and after that edit, and the two periods were not compared. The paving cost guide was edited on 10 November 2026, after the last scans, so that edit is not reflected in these results.
WHAT IS AI OVERVIEW?
Google's AI Overview is the written answer Google shows above the search results on many searches, with links to the websites it drew on listed as its sources.
WHAT IS AI MODE?
AI Mode is Google's chat-style search. The searcher asks a question and gets a written answer with linked sources, rather than a page of results.
WHAT IS STRUCTURED DATA?
Structured data is code on a page that tells Google and other machines, in a fixed format, what the page is and what it covers, such as an article with a set of questions and answers.

Not Your Average SEO Company

One screenshot of one AI answer doesn't prove much. We count the links in every answer our weekly scans collect and set the client site against every other site cited in the same replies, as we did here.

Want AI Answers Linking to Your Website?

Talk to us about getting your pages cited when customers ask AI what a job costs.

More results.