SEOptimize.3 of 20 seats openFree consultation
Home services case study

AI Answers Recommended Beehive Plumbing 495 Times, Ahead of Four Named Rivals

Across 1,397 scan results pooled from four AI engines in the four weekly scans from 19 October to 9 November 2026, including checks where no AI Overview appeared, 495 recommended Beehive Plumbing, against 344 for Valley Plumbing and 331 for Millcreek Plumbing.

Stat
495 vs 344
Label
AI answers recommending Beehive, pooled across four engines, against Valley Plumbing
Stat
210 vs 136
Label
Gemini answers linking to Beehive's website, against Valley
Stat
11 of 19
Label
Questions where Beehive was recommended more than any named rival
Stat
73 vs 41
Label
Answers to three drain-cleaning questions recommending Beehive, pooled across four engines, against Valley

We asked ChatGPT, Gemini, Google AI Mode and AI Overviews the same 19 local plumbing questions every week, 18 naming Salt Lake City and 1 naming Bountiful. Pooled across the four engines, Beehive came out ahead of every rival we track, led them on 11 of the 19 questions, and was linked in more Gemini answers than any of them. Gemini linked beehiveplumbing.com in 210 of its 379 answers, against 136 for Valley and 82 for Millcreek.

01 Background

Who Is Beehive Plumbing?

Beehive Plumbing is a Salt Lake City plumbing company. Their website covers water heater repair, replacement and installation, drain cleaning and hydro jetting, sewer line repair, emergency plumbing, water main replacement and commercial plumbing.

They also keep location pages for towns outside the city, Bountiful among them.

What Sets Them Apart

  1. 01

    A page for each job. Drains, water heaters, water mains and commercial work each have their own page.

  2. 02

    Pages for nearby towns. Bountiful has its own location and plumbing services pages.

  1. The Challenge

    Their services were already in place. The open question was whether AI assistants would name Beehive when a homeowner asked them which plumber to hire.

    The Solution

    We rebuilt its city service pages, fixed the site underneath them and kept its business listings up to date across the web, alongside the AI-search work in every SEOptimize engagement.

02 The Problem: Four Named Rivals in the Same Answers

An AI assistant does not hand a homeowner ten search results to scroll. It writes one answer.

Context

All but one of the questions we track are hiring questions. They include "best emergency plumbing in Salt Lake City", "drain cleaning near Salt Lake City open on weekends", "recommend a water heater installation in Salt Lake City with good reviews". None of them names a company.

Gap

We track four rival plumbers in those answers: Valley Plumbing, Millcreek Plumbing, Manwill Plumbing and Neerings Plumbing. No other plumber is counted. Across the seven weekly scans from 28 September to 9 November 2026, Gemini's answers to these questions carried between 3.76 and 6.94 links each on average, so a plumber's own site competes for a handful of places.

Impact

When an answer leaves Beehive out, the homeowner who asked sees the rivals it names instead.

Significance

The tracked questions cover jobs Beehive sells, drain cleaning and water main replacement among them.

03 Strategy: SEOptimize's Game Plan

The plan gave each job a clear page and the whole site clean, consistent signals:

  1. 1.

    A page for each job in the city. Drains, water heaters, sewer lines and emergencies each get a page that answers that job for Salt Lake City.

  2. 2.

    A site that loads the right page. Old addresses redirect to the live page, so a visitor or a crawler following an old link reaches the right content.

  3. 3.

    A clear description of the business. Structured data and FAQ markup tell machines what Beehive is and what it offers.

  4. 4.

    Up-to-date business details. We keep Beehive's Business Profile up to date and list its name, address and phone number on business directories.

  5. 5.

    AI-search work. We work on how Beehive appears in AI Overviews and AI assistants, as we do for every client.

Each content item we publish goes through the same launch steps once it is live: structured data, internal links, image optimisation and a request for Google to index it.

04 Execution: Our Approach

  1. 01

    Service Pages for Each Job

    Rewrites of six service pages for the city were due in October 2025: water heater repair, water heater replacement, drain cleaning, hydro jetting, emergency plumber and sewer line repair. Work moving those rewrites back to their original addresses and retiring the duplicate copies finished in November 2025.

    Work on Salt Lake City pages for plumber, plumbing repair, emergency plumber, drain cleaning and sewer line repair finished in May 2026. Work on blog posts on commercial plumbing maintenance, emergency plumbing steps for homeowners, and hydro jetting for local homes finished in August. Work on four Salt Lake City service pages (plumber, sewer line repair, main water line repair and trenchless sewer repair) finished in September.

  2. 02

    Technical Foundation

    In April 2026 we fixed a redirect chain on the drain cleaning service address. We also set 301 redirects for eight service page addresses that returned a "page not found" error, so old links reach the live page. The same month we refreshed the top 14 blog posts and the Utah drain cleaning and emergency plumber pages.

    On the homepage we swapped the hero slider for a team photo and optimised the page in March 2026, then updated its content in April.

  3. 03

    Structured Data and Business Details

    We optimised Beehive's schema markup in January 2026, implemented structured data in February and added FAQ markup in April. That code tells machines what Beehive is and what it offers. On the Business Profile, we updated the business information in October 2025 and listed every service with a description in March 2026. In August we refreshed the questions and answers on the main Salt Lake City listing.

    Citation builds in January, March and May 2026 listed Beehive's name, address and phone number on business directories.

  4. 04

    AI-Search Work

    AI-search work is part of every SEOptimize engagement, Beehive's included: we work on how a client shows up in AI Overviews and in AI assistants. It runs alongside the pages and fixes above.

Timeline

  1. October and November 2025. Six city service pages rewritten and moved back to their original addresses; Business Profile updated.
  2. January to April 2026. Structured data and FAQ markup in place, citations built, homepage refreshed, redirects fixed.
  3. May to September 2026. Work finished on service pages and blog posts; Business Profile questions refreshed.

05 Outcome: The Results

Across 1,397 scan results in the four scans, including 135 checks where no AI Overview appeared, 495 recommended Beehive, against 344 for Valley Plumbing and 331 for Millcreek Plumbing. Beehive led the four named rivals across the pooled results and under both versions of the tracker's grading. The scans began on 28 September 2026, so these results show where Beehive stood against the named rivals during monitoring, not a change from before the campaign.

  • Ahead on three of the four engines. ChatGPT (151 of 380 answers, Valley 133), Gemini (228 of 379, Valley 190) and Google AI Mode (87 of 380, Millcreek 66). Millcreek was recommended more often in AI Overviews (36 vs 29 of 258 scan results).

  • Linked more on Gemini. Gemini linked beehiveplumbing.com in 210 of 379 answers. Valley's site was linked in 136 and Millcreek's in 82. The link lead is on Gemini only: counted across all four engines together, Valley's site was linked in more answers. The homepage was the Beehive page it linked most, in 71 answers.

  • Recommended more than any named rival on 11 of the 19 questions, including all three drain-cleaning questions, all three emergency plumbing questions and the Bountiful question.

AI Recommendations, Head to Head

AI answers recommended Beehive 495 times, Valley Plumbing 3441,397 scan results pooled across four AI engines, 19 local questions, four weekly scans, 19 October to 9 November 2026
Beehive Plumbing495
Valley Plumbing344
Millcreek Plumbing331
Manwill Plumbing30
Neerings Plumbing9

Source: GEO/AEO Command Center weekly scans (Supabase geo_tracker), answers judged as recommending each plumber · ChatGPT, Gemini, Google AI Mode, AI Overviews · scans of 19 October to 9 November 2026 · pulled 2026-11-11

Every bar counts the same 1,397 scan results, so each plumber was judged against the same questions in the same weeks.

Gemini Links to Each Plumber's Website

Gemini linked Beehive's website in 210 of 379 answersAnswers linking each plumber's own site, four weekly scans, 19 October to 9 November 2026
Beehive Plumbing210
Valley Plumbing136
Millcreek Plumbing82
Manwill Plumbing6
Neerings Plumbing0

Source: GEO/AEO Command Center weekly scans (Supabase geo_tracker), Gemini answers linking each plumber's website · scans of 19 October to 9 November 2026 · pulled 2026-11-11

In those four scans, Gemini linked Beehive's website in more answers than any of the four named rivals' sites.

Proof Point: Drain Cleaning

On the three Salt Lake City drain-cleaning questions, pooled across the four engines, AI answers recommended Beehive 73 times in 219 scan results, against 41 for Valley and 18 for Millcreek. ChatGPT recommended Beehive in 36 of its 60 answers. Gemini recommended it in 35, and linked Beehive's Salt Lake City drain-cleaning page in 38 of its 60 answers, against 20 that linked Valley's site.

How We Measured This

Window:
the four weekly scans from 19 October to 9 November 2026. The tracker's scans start 28 September 2026, so there is no year-earlier comparison; the benchmark is the four named rivals in the same answers.
Questions:
19 unchanged plumbing questions that name no company, 18 naming Salt Lake City and 1 naming Bountiful, asked five times a week on each of the four engines (Perplexity and Claude are not scanned). Requests ran from a United States location; the city is in the question.
Measures:
an answer counts as a recommendation when the tracker's grader judged that it recommended the plumber, and as a link when it cited the plumber's website. The sample is 19 questions on 4 engines over 4 weekly scans: 1,397 scan results, an average of 18.4 per question per engine, and 379 Gemini answers.
Note:
ChatGPT moved to a newer model (gpt-5-6 to gpt-6) at the 12 October scan, so every ChatGPT answer in the four-scan window comes from gpt-6; the first two weekly scans used gpt-5-6. The grader's prompt changed at the 26 October scan, so the 1,397 scan results combine one scan graded the old way and three graded the new way; Beehive led under both (100 against Millcreek's 85 in the first scan, 395 against Valley's 271 in the other three). Millcreek was recommended more often in AI Overviews (36 vs 29), and 188 of the 357 AI Overview checks across the seven weekly scans were blank, with no summary shown; the blank checks in the four-scan window stay in the 1,397 for every plumber. AI Overview checks per scan tripled from the 2 November scan (95, against 29 to 38 before), so AI Overviews, where Millcreek led, carry more weight in the 1,397. Gemini linked more sites per answer in three of the four scans than in the earlier ones; in the 26 October scan, at the earlier level, it still linked Beehive in more answers than any named rival.
WHAT IS AI OVERVIEWS?
AI Overviews are the AI-written summaries Google shows above some search results. Google AI Mode is a separate Google Search tab where AI writes the whole answer.
WHAT IS BUSINESS PROFILE?
A Google Business Profile is the free listing that shows a business on Google Maps and in local search results, with its phone number, reviews and website link.
WHAT IS STRUCTURED DATA?
Structured data is code on a page that tells Google and other machines, in a fixed format, what the business is and what it offers.

Not Your Average SEO Company

We ask the same questions every week, count how often each rival is recommended or linked in the same answers, and say exactly how each figure was counted. Every AI figure in Beehive's study was counted that way.

Want AI Assistants Recommending Your Business?

Talk to us about AI search work measured against the rivals named in the same answers.

More results.