SEOptimize.3 of 20 seats openFree consultation
Home services case study

Superior Overtook Kinetico in AI Recommendations on Three Salt Lake City Water-Treatment Questions

Across three Salt Lake City water treatment questions asked in ChatGPT, Gemini, Google AI Mode and AI Overviews, Superior was recommended in 92 of 275 scan results pooled across the four engines, 12 October to 9 November 2026, against 63 for named rival Kinetico. In the first two weekly scans, 99 scan results in all, Kinetico led 25 to 15.

Stat
92 of 275
Label
Scan results recommending Superior, four engines pooled, 12 Oct to 9 Nov 2026
Stat
63 of 275
Label
The same scan results recommending Kinetico
Stat
25 vs 15 of 99
Label
Scan results recommending Kinetico vs Superior in the first two scans, 28 Sep and 5 Oct 2026
Stat
96 of 370
Label
Scan results on four reverse osmosis questions citing Superior's website, 12 Oct to 9 Nov 2026, about as often as Culligan's sites (95)

SEOptimize completed four new or rewritten water pages for Superior Water & Air in October 2026, on top of our AI-search work. The shift in AI answers is consistent with the October water-page work, during and after it.

01 Background

Who Is Superior Water & Air?

Superior Water & Air is a Salt Lake City home-services company. It sells and services water heaters, water softeners, whole-home filtration, reverse osmosis and water treatment systems, plus furnaces, air conditioning, indoor air quality, plumbing and drain cleaning.

Its town pages reach well past Salt Lake, from Ogden and Layton down to St. George, plus a page for Boise, Idaho. Homeowners reach the company by phone or through an estimate request.

What Sets Them Apart

  1. 01

    Water and air from one company. Treatment, filtration and softeners sit beside heating, cooling, air quality and plumbing.

  2. 02

    Dedicated water pages. Water treatment, reverse osmosis and whole-home filtration each have a page of their own in the site's water section.

  1. The Challenge

    They had the services and a water treatment page. But in the earliest scans of AI answers to three Salt Lake water treatment questions, Kinetico was named more often than Superior.

    The Solution

    We built and rebuilt the core water pages on Superior's site in October 2026, then took each one through our launch steps.

02 The Problem: AI Answers Favoured Kinetico

Kinetico came up more often. In those scans, 28 September and 5 October, Kinetico was named in 44 scan results and Superior in 32.

Context

A homeowner can now type a question into ChatGPT or Google and get one written answer back. We tracked three of those questions: the best water treatment systems in Salt Lake City, one with good reviews, and one open on weekends.

Gap

Being named is not the same as being recommended. An answer can list several companies and still recommend one of them rather than the others, and in those early scans that one was Kinetico more often than Superior.

Scan results naming each brand, 28 Sep and 5 Oct 2026

  • Kinetico44
  • Superior32

44 vs 32Kinetico named more often than Superior in the first two scans

Impact

None of these questions names a company. So an answer that recommends Kinetico puts a rival forward on a question that names no company.

Significance

These answers cite web pages as their sources, and Superior's own water pages were the part of that we could change directly.

03 Strategy: SEOptimize's Game Plan

We wanted clear pages for the core water services.

So the plan had four parts:

  1. 1.

    A water-section page for each of these services. Whole-home filtration, water quality and reverse osmosis each get a page in the site's water section that answers that one question; the reverse osmosis page is a rewrite.

  2. 2.

    Rewrite the main water treatment page again. /water/water-treatment/, already rewritten in August, gets another rewrite.

  3. 3.

    Launch every page the same way. Structured data, internal links, image optimisation and a request for Google to index it.

  4. 4.

    Check the business details. Review structured data and company details for consistency.

04 Execution: Our Approach

  1. 01

    The October Water Pages

    Work on the whole-home water filtration page and a rewrite of the reverse osmosis page were both completed on 2 October 2026.

    A new water quality page at /water/, the top page of the water section, was completed on 5 October.

  2. 02

    The Water Treatment Page, Rewritten Again

    We rewrote /water/water-treatment/ in August, and completed another rewrite on 22 October.

  3. 03

    Launch Steps and Site Checks

    Each of the four pages then went through our launch steps once it was live. We checked the structured data and company details for consistency in mid-October, alongside that month's technical fixes.

  4. 04

    AI-Search Work

    We do AI-search work for every SEOptimize client, on how a business shows up in AI Overviews and AI assistants as well as in Google's results.

Timeline

  1. August 2026. /water/water-treatment/ rewritten.
  2. 2 October 2026. Whole-home filtration page and reverse osmosis rewrite completed.
  3. 5 October 2026. Water quality page completed.
  4. Mid-October 2026. Consistency check of structured data and business details.
  5. 22 October 2026. Another /water/water-treatment/ rewrite completed.

05 Outcome: The Results

On those three questions, Superior moved ahead of Kinetico. In 275 scan results from 12 October to 9 November 2026, including 23 checks where no AI Overview appeared, Superior was recommended 92 times (33.5%) and Kinetico 63 (22.9%), pooled across the four engines; Superior led in ChatGPT, Gemini and AI Mode, while AI Overviews, with few recommendations either way, was about level. In the first two scans, 99 scan results, it ran the other way: Kinetico 25, Superior 15.

That shift is consistent with the October water-page work, during and after it, rather than proof that the pages moved it. Superior was also named in a larger proportion of scan results, 32 of 99 in the first two scans and 121 of 275 in the next five, while Kinetico went from 44 of 99 to 97 of 275. Both mention figures are pooled too; on Gemini alone, Kinetico was named more often.

  • Share of voice moved Superior's way. Kinetico's share was above Superior's at the start and again on 12 October; Superior's was above Kinetico's in each of the four scans after that, 19 October to 9 November, all engines pooled: 51% to 60%, against 35% to 45%, with the other four tracked competitors at 0% to 8% together. Share of voice is a brand's share of all the times AI answers named Superior or one of its five tracked competitors, so each week adds to 100%; untracked brands, including Culligan and Utah Water Systems, fall outside it.

  • On these questions, Google AI Mode recommended Superior more than twice as often as Kinetico. Over the five weeks, AI Mode recommended Superior in 28 of 75 answers and Kinetico in 13.

  • Reverse osmosis answers cited Superior's site about as often as Culligan's. On four Salt Lake reverse osmosis questions, superiorwaterandair.com was cited in 96 of 370 scan results, 60 of them in Gemini. Culligan's two sites were cited in 95, Water & Wellness's in 89 and Kinetico's in 25.

Recommendations: First Two Scans vs. Next Five Scans

First two scans vs. next five: Superior overtook KineticoScan results recommending each brand; bar height is the share of scan results in that period
SuperiorFirst two scans (28 Sep, 5 Oct)15 of 99
KineticoFirst two scans (28 Sep, 5 Oct)25 of 99
SuperiorNext five scans (12 Oct to 9 Nov)92 of 275
KineticoNext five scans (12 Oct to 9 Nov)63 of 275

Source: GEO/AEO Command Center weekly AI scans (Supabase, schema geo_tracker), three Salt Lake City water treatment questions in ChatGPT, Gemini, Google AI Mode and AI Overviews, up to 5 answers per question per engine per week, failed answers left out · weeks of 28 Sep to 9 Nov 2026 · pulled 2026-11-11

Kinetico was recommended in about the same proportion of scan results in both periods, while Superior moved ahead of it, with or without ChatGPT counted.

Reverse Osmosis Citations, Four Separate Questions

Reverse osmosis answers cite Superior about as often as CulliganScan results citing each brand's website, out of the same 370
Superior96
Culligan (2 sites)95
Water & Wellness (2 sites)89
Kinetico (2 sites)25

Source: GEO/AEO Command Center weekly AI scans (Supabase, schema geo_tracker, citations table), four Salt Lake City reverse osmosis questions in ChatGPT, Gemini, Google AI Mode and AI Overviews · weeks of 12 Oct to 9 Nov 2026 · pulled 2026-11-11

Over the five scans, Superior's one website was cited about as often as Culligan's two together.

How We Measured This

Source:
the GEO/AEO Command Center's weekly scans, five scans per question per engine each week, with failed scans left out. None of the seven weekly scans was missed, and every failed scan was an AI Overview check: on the three questions, AI Overviews returned 50 counted results in the five later scans and 9 in the first two, against 75 and 30 for each other engine; on reverse osmosis, 30 of 400 scans failed, all of them AI Overview checks. Five answers is a small sample, so results are quoted as totals or ranges over several weeks, never one week alone. The first period is the two scans of 28 September and 5 October, which overlap the start of the October work; the second is the next five scans, 12 October to 9 November. Bases are scan results: they keep AI Overview checks where no AI Overview appeared (23 of the 275 and 2 of the 99 on the three questions; 42 of the 370 on reverse osmosis), which stay in every brand's total.
Recommended:
an answer counts when the Command Center's judge marks it as recommending that brand. None of the three questions names Superior or a rival.
Share of voice:
counts Superior and its five tracked competitors only. In the last three scans, untracked Utah Water Systems and Culligan were named about as often as Superior.
Engines:
ChatGPT, Gemini, Google AI Mode and AI Overviews. Perplexity and Claude are not tracked for Superior.
Note:
ChatGPT's model changed from gpt-5-6 to gpt-6 at the 12 October scan. Without ChatGPT, Superior still moves from behind Kinetico to ahead: 14 vs 19 of 69 in the first two scans, 72 vs 54 of 200 in the next five. The judge was updated from the 26 October scan. Taken together, the 12 and 19 October scans, which were judged the same way as the first two scans, also put Superior ahead of Kinetico. The 5 October scan ran after the first two October pages were completed. Dates of our work are the dates each task was completed, not confirmed publish dates. In the later scans, Gemini's answers cited more pages and named Kinetico more often, and 23 of the 50 AI Overview checks showed no AI Overview, which lowers the later rates. None of the three questions has a measured search volume, so this shows how AI answers them, not how many people ask.
WHAT IS STRUCTURED DATA?
Structured data is code on a page that tells Google, in a fixed format, what Superior Water & Air is and what it offers.

Not Your Average SEO Company

Every week, we put our three Salt Lake water treatment questions and four reverse osmosis questions to four AI engines, five times each, and recorded which companies each answer named and recommended, and which websites it cited.

Want AI Answers Recommending You Over Your Rivals?

Talk to us about getting your business named, and recommended, when customers ask AI who to call.

More results.